Epub 2015 Mar 24. Single imputation procedures are those where one value for a missing data element is filled in without defining an explicit model for the partially missing data. A second technique is to create dummy variables for whether a variable is missing. 2022 Apr 14;10(4):E448-E458. Whether an observation is missing has nothing to do with the missing values, but it does have to do with the values of an individuals observed variables. Doing so can lead to imputing outliers, creating more bias than just imputing the skewed variable. impute.IterativeImputer ). Single imputation will generally lead to underestimation of standard errors. When we have \(n_1\) cases with complete data on Y and \(n_0\) cases with missing data on Y. I hate spam & you may opt out anytime: Privacy Policy. Why? If the data is numerical, we can use mean and median values to replace else if the data is categorical, we can use mode which is a frequently occurring value. Missing at Random, MAR, means there is a systematic relationship between the propensity of missing values and the observed data, but not the missing data. Rio de Janeiro, RJ, 2008. Results: This type of imputation works by filling the missing data multiple times. Random draws form the residual distribution of each imputed variable and add those random numbers to the imputed values. Maybe mode imputation would provide better results, but we'll leave that up to you. For predicting categorical variables, Fishers optimum scoring method is used. With singular imputation methods, the mean, median, or some other statistic is used to impute the missing values. Imputation of missing data is one strategy to eliminate this technical problem. After I clicked "OK" on impute missing data, I noted random missing data is still available in the dataset of imputation_1, imputation_2, imputation_3, imputation_4 and imputation_5. Your home for data science. K-NN is quite sensitive to outliers in the data (. ), accurate standard errors of those parameter estimates, and therefore, accurate p-values in the analysis. 4,1/4; and 5;1/5 (nearest to the corner). For every observation that needs to be imputed, the algorithm identifies k closest observations based on some types distance (e.g., Euclidean) and computes the weighted average (weighted based on distance) of these k obs. Raman R, Chen W, Harhay MO, Thompson JL, Ely EW, Pandharipande PP, Patel MB. Join the Discussion Hence, no assumption about function form of f.Instead, it tries to estimate f such that it can be as close to the data points as possible. More precisely, I'm going to investigate the popularity of the following five imputation methods: Mean Imputation Regression Imp. Multivariate missing data present a challenge for imputation methods due to in- terdependent incomplete variables and that each incomplete variable has its own set of correlated predictors. eCollection 2020. Multiple imputation is one of the approaches that . : Note on a air method to estimate missing pollution data. r mice - "sample" imputation method not working correctly. Unable to load your collection due to an error, Unable to load your delegates due to an error. Note: You need to read carefully on how your software specify the sample size because it will alter the standard errors. # PFC (proportion of falsely classified) is used to represent error derived from imputing categorical values. Epub 2014 Dec 10. In this example, points above Disclaimer, National Library of Medicine Missing data is a ubiquitous cross-domain problem persistent in the context of big data analytics. BMC Med Res Methodol. However, if you have certain type of missing data (e.g., non-random missing data) in the \(x\)s variable (independent variables), then you can still salvage your collected data points with imputation. Some possible scenarios for missing data. Since bagging works well on categorical variable too, we dont need to remove them here. Regression imputation and hot deck imputation seem to have increased their popularity until 2013. It is very common in real-world data. For example, people with low education will be less likely to report it. We took out missingness from three cases in a block having low missingness of 5% as well as higher levels at 30% and 50%. And while this is true for unbiasedness, you can get inconsistent results if you run the multiple imputation more than once. Empirical studies are carried out with the help of data borrowed from natural populations to show the superiorities of the suggested imputation methods over usual mean, ratio and regression. Mice: Multivariate Imputation by Chained Equations in R. Journal of Statistical Software. \end{cases} One type of imputation algorithm is univariate, which imputes values in the i-th feature dimension using only non-missing values in that feature dimension (e.g. For example, one could use bootstrap to generate different data set with replacement, and for each data set, calculate the starting values by EM estimates. For more information on the algorithm mechanics, you can refer to the Research Paper. To avoid such problem, you can set seed when doing your analysis to ensure its reproducibility. For example, to combine hot-deck and regression imputation to predict the missing value (this technique is a little different from the one shown below). Will give poor results on encoded categorical features (do NOT use it on categorical features). Quite accurate compared to other methods. 2015 May 30;34(12):2062-80. doi: 10.1002/sim.6475. 1- Hot deck Imputation: the idea, in this case, is to use some criteria of similarity to cluster the data before executing the data imputation. 2- Regression Imputation: the missing value is replaced for the predicted value generated by the regression of the missing item on items observed for the unit. MICE can handle different types of variables while the variables in MVN need to be normally distributed or transformed to approximate normality. Authors sharing sensitive information, make sure youre on a federal If their responses on those key items differ by very much, thats good evidence that the data are MNAR. J Psychiatr Res. analysis; (f) missingness depends directly on the unobserved outcome, Meta-analysis (assuming a common effect) of available case analyses (ACA) Saraiya TC, Jarnecke AM, Rothbaum AO, Wangelin B, McTeague LM, Acierno R, Brown DG, Bristol E, Feigl H, Reese M, Cobb AR, Harley B, Adams RJ, Back SE. However, at higher levels of missingness (60-80%), Markov, random, median, and mean imputation performed best on average. Epub 2021 Feb 15. In their dataset, a variable amount of data was missing for several variables, which the authors addressed by multiple imputation. Multiple Imputation for Missing Data: A Cautionary Tale, Sociological Methods and Research, 28, 301-309. AU - Wang, Wenjia. For example, if women really are less likely to tell you their weight than men, a chi-square test will tell you that the percentage of missing data on the weight variable is higher for women than men. Missing Completely at Random, MCAR, means there is no relationship between the missingness of the data and any values, observed or missing. Imputation methods are those where the missing data are filled in to create a complete data matrix that can be analyzed using standard methods. Statistical Analysis with Missing Data. Figure 1 illustrates these concepts and the steps in the multiple imputation process are as follows: 1- For each attribute that has a missing value in a data set record, a set of n values to be imputed is generated; 2- A statistical analysis is performed on each data set, generated from the use of one of the n replacement suggestions generated in the previous item; 3- The results of the analyses performed are combined to produce a set of results. MICE imputes data on variable by variable basis whereas MVN uses a joint modeling approach based on multivariate normal distribution. x_{ij} & \text{if } (i,j) \in \cal{O} \\ for outcomes and for missingness, but cannot be incorporated into the Refresh the page, check Medium 's site status, or find something interesting to read. Imputation using univariate methods may provide a reasonable solution to addressing missing data for short-term monitoring of air pollutants, especially in resource-limited areas. Little RJA, Rubin DB. Some others have the option to just ignore them (ie. -. If \(X_1\) has missing data, then it is regressed on the rest of the variables. Book Description. -, Hollis S, Campbell F. What is meant by intention to treat analysis? 6- Imputation Using Deep Learning (Datawig): This method works very well with categorical and non-numerical features. Stat Med. D= If you want to impute non-linear relationship, such as interaction between 2 variables and 1 variable is categorical. If the data is proportion, logit-transform, impute, then de-transform the missing data. 1 & \text{data on X are missing} \\ The iterative process allows us to get random draws from the joint posterior distribution of both data nd parameters, given the observed data. the rate of convergence for EM algorithm should be the minimum threshold for DA. \end{cases} There is a very useful test for MCAR, Littles test. Then it uses the model to predict missing values in the variable with the help of observed values. There are numerous ways to perform imputation in R programming language, and choosing the best one usually boils down to domain knowledge. Required fields are marked *. The idea of imputation is both seductive and dangerous. In bootstrapping, different bootstrap resamples are used for each of multiple imputations. In implicit modeling, the focus is on an algorithm, which implies an underlying model. Get regular updates on the latest tutorials, offers & news at Statistics Globe. Doesnt account for the uncertainty in the imputations. This requires the following two steps: ffl Imputation: Replace each unknown missing value by multiple (say m ? the first set of estimates are used to impute first set of missing values using regression, then second set of estimates are used for second set and so on. Univariate methods of Markov, random, and mean imputations were the best performing methods that yielded 24-hour mean concentrations with the lowest error and highest R2 values across all levels of missingness. There are some set rules to decide which strategy to use for particular types of missing values, but beyond that, you should experiment and check which model works best for your dataset. In this way, we can define composite imputation as the application of one or more strategies in the process of complementing missing data in an attribute v of a B database. Read more on The Missing Book by Nicholas Tierney & Allison Horst, Usually 5. PLoS One. Computationally expensive. There will be missing values because the data might be corrupted or some collection error. The k nearest neighbours is an algorithm that is used for simple classification. A few of the well known attempts to deal with missing data include: hot deck and cold deck imputation; listwise and pairwise deletion; mean imputation; non-negative matrix factorization; regression imputation; last observation carried forward; stochastic imputation; and multiple imputation. Soares[2007] also introduces the missing data imputation committee concepts that consist to evaluate with some statistical method, between all predictions, the more plausible value. Expand 42 PDF Save Alert Note: the missingness on Y can be correlated with the missingness on X We can compare the value of other variables for the observations with missing data, and observations without missing data. The higher the proportion of missing, the more iterations. Note that choosing larger IMORs (with This technique is similar to substitution, but in this case, a constant value is used and in the substitution technique different values can be used to substitute the missing values. \begin{cases} Take the average of all the values in the feature f1 that belongs to class 0 or 1 and replace the missing values. The four groups are: Population, Baseline, Before, and Before and After (B/A). 2001;323:4246. We also recommend a strategy for undertaking sensitivity analyses, in which the IMORs are varied over plausible ranges. \], \(e_i = \frac{y_i - bx_i}{\sqrt{s^2(1-k/n_1)}}\), # Auxiliary variable 4 (categorical variable), ##### Impute data via predictive mean matching (single imputation)#####, # SInce single imputation underestiamtes stnadard errors, we use multiple imputaiton, ##### Predictive mean matching (multiple imputation)#####, # Combine imputed Y and X1-X4 (for convenience), # First 6 rows of our multiply imputed data, #> y.0 y.1 y.2 y.3 y.4 y.5 x1 x2 x3 x4, #> 1 8 8 8 8 8 8 38 -3 6 1, #> 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 50 -9 5 0, #> 3 5 5 5 5 5 5 43 20 5 1, #> 4 NA -6 -4 -4 -1 -3 9 13 3 0, #> 5 -4 -4 -4 -4 -4 -4 40 -10 6 0, #> 6 NA -8 5 -4 1 4 29 -6 5 1, ## linear regression for each imputed data set - 5 regression are run, #> term estimate std.error statistic p.value nobs, #> , #> 1 (Intercept) 6.44 1.77 3.63 0.00664 11, #> 2 y4 -0.381 0.162 -2.35 0.0468 11, #> 3 x1 0.458 0.101 4.56 0.00186 11, #> 4 (Intercept) 6.17 2.02 3.06 0.0156 11, #> 5 y4 -0.351 0.183 -1.92 0.0914 11, #> 6 x1 0.443 0.117 3.79 0.00535 11, #> 7 (Intercept) 6.47 2.02 3.21 0.0125 11, #> 8 y4 -0.360 0.186 -1.93 0.0893 11, #> 9 x1 0.430 0.114 3.77 0.00549 11, #> 10 (Intercept) 6.51 2.63 2.48 0.0384 11, #> 11 y4 -0.358 0.242 -1.48 0.178 11, #> 12 x1 0.433 0.149 2.91 0.0195 11, #> 13 (Intercept) 6.15 2.37 2.60 0.0318 11, #> 14 y4 -0.362 0.219 -1.65 0.137 11, #> 15 x1 0.478 0.138 3.46 0.00855 11, ## pool coefficients and standard errors across all 5 regression models, #> term m estimate ubar b t dfcom df, #> 1 (Intercept) 5 6.3487398 4.76263432 0.0300416474 4.79868430 8 6.495687, #> 2 y4 5 -0.3623970 0.04025189 0.0001255017 0.04040250 8 6.520908, #> 3 x1 5 0.4485592 0.01560878 0.0003990336 0.01608762 8 6.341712, #> term estimate std.error statistic df p.value, #> 1 (Intercept) 6.3487398 2.1905899 2.898187 6.495687 0.02504369, #> 2 y4 -0.3623970 0.2010037 -1.802937 6.520908 0.11751237, #> 3 x1 0.4485592 0.1268370 3.536502 6.341712 0.01119463, #> [1] -66.055957 -96.980053 -28.921432 -4.175686 -54.480798 -27.207102, \(\hat{x}_{ij} = \sum_{m=1}^M \hat{a}_{im}\hat{b}_{jm}\), \(\tilde{x}_{ij} \leftarrow \sum_{m=1}^M \hat{a}_{im}\hat{b}_{jm}\), #> mae mse rmse mape, #> 0.2870303 0.1301598 0.3607767 0.1021485, # iris.mis[,!names(iris.mis) %in% c("Sepal.Length")]. But which of the imputation methods should I use? builds a random forest model for each variable. 2001). Missing completely at, Meta-analysis (assuming a common effect), Meta-analysis (assuming a common effect) of available case analyses (ACA) from each of, LAbb plot providing graphical representation, LAbb plot providing graphical representation of the proposed sensitivity analysis strategy, representing risks, MeSH might lead to implausible values (e.g. This method could only be used in the case of linear models such as linear regression, factor analysis, or SEM. 2022 Dec;156:467-475. doi: 10.1016/j.jpsychires.2022.10.056. There is a bunch of approaches out there and sometimes it seems like everybody is using a different methodology. This re-introduces some variation that your software can incorporate in order to give your model accurate estimates of standard error. Missing data are often encountered when performing short-term monitoring (<24 h) of air pollutants with real-time monitors, especially in resource-limited areas. This study aspires to impute the rainfall missing values by using various imputation methods such as Replacing by Mmean (RM), Nearest Neighbor (NN), Random Forest (RF), Non-linear Interactive . The https:// ensures that you are connecting to the their reciprocals) leads to traveling along curved paths towards the By default, this value is 5. We can use it in production. -, Whitehead A, Whitehead J. Most studies . Serious games and eating behaviors: A systematic review of the last 5 years (2018-2022). Maintain the relationship with other variables (i.e., preserve dependence structure among features, unlike 11.2.4.1). Several reasons that contribute to this negative views could be: If you have missing data on \(y\) (dependent variable), you probability would not be able to do any imputation appropriately. Create multiplicative terms before imputing. On this website, I provide statistics tutorials as well as code in Python and R programming. risks among the haloperidol trials. Lets see some other ways to impute the missing values before training: Note: All the examples below use the California Housing Dataset from Scikit-learn. Environ Int. We review some common strategies, such as simple imputation of positive or negative outcomes, and develop a general approach involving ;informative missingness odds ratios' (IMORs). The site is secure. Using multiple imputation? Let us use the K-Nearest Neighbor algorithm and take k=2 to train our model since it is simple and uses neighborhood concept. Step 4: Repeat the process for every variable. the dotted line represent superiority of haloperidol, and points below Refresh the page, check Medium 's site. In other cases than regression analysis, other sophisticated methods can yield better estimates compared to listwise deletion. Remember that there are three goals of multiple imputation, or any missing data technique: Dont round off imputations for dummy variables. Since the value is picked at random, it adds some variability, which might come in handy when calculating standard errors. ffl complete-case analysis: Analyze each of the m completed . Essentially, Simple Data Imputation is a method applied to impute one value for each missing item. Each one of these n values is assigned as a plausible value and n new datasets are created as if a simple imputation has occurred in each dataset. The methods are defined below and summarized in Table 1. Perhaps people with more education are less likely to reveal their income than those with less education, The missing data mechanism is ignorable when. Recent research, however, has found that rounding off imputed values actually leads to biased parameter estimates in the analysis model. It yields out of bag imputation error estimate. If your rate of missing data is very, very small (2-3%) it doesnt matter what technique you use. MSc. Evaluating the impact of imputations for missing participant outcome data in a network meta-analysis. (2019).Statistical analysis with missing data, volume 793.Wiley. Alternative imputation methods (observed data, last observation carried forward [LOCF], modified NRI, and multiple imputation [MI]) were applied in this analysis and the . Can be applied to any statistical test (SEM, multi-level regression, etc.). Note Monotonic means that if you are missing data on X1, then that observation also has missing data on all other variables that come after it. The output dataset consists of the . eCollection 2022. See this image and copyright information in PMC. In another word, there is a systematic relationship between the propensity of missing values and the observed data, but not the missing data. \[ # knn is not appropriate for categorical variables, # should exclude the dependent variable: Sepal.Length, #> 0.2318182 0.1038636 0.3222788 0.0823571, # since Species is a factor, and exclude dependent variable "Sepal.Length", # number of iterations taken to impute missing values, # method used in imputation. If the correlation among variables are low, pairwise deletion is more efficient estimates than listwise. It has some functions that can handle categorical data (Feature Encoder). Chapter 11 Imputation (Missing Data) | A Guide on Data Analysis 11 Imputation (Missing Data) Imputation is a statistical procedure where you replace missing data with some values Unit imputation = single data point Item imputation = single feature value Imputation is usually seen as the illegitimate child of statistical analysis. Handle different types of variables while the variables more on the missing data, then de-transform the values... Are low, pairwise deletion is more efficient estimates than listwise, check Medium & # ;! Website, I provide Statistics tutorials as well as code in Python and R programming on an algorithm that used. To represent error derived from imputing categorical values Table 1 other variables ( i.e., preserve dependence structure features. Variable basis whereas MVN uses a joint modeling approach based on Multivariate normal distribution R. of... Seem to have increased their popularity until 2013 the case of linear models such as regression..., 28, 301-309 others have the option to just ignore them ( ie maintain the relationship other. Be the minimum threshold for DA unable to load your collection due to an,! Tutorials as well as code in Python and R programming several variables, which implies an underlying.. Falsely classified ) is used for simple classification 10 ( 4 ) this... But we & # x27 ; S site Journal of Statistical software if the correlation among variables are low pairwise... Since the value is picked at random, it adds some variability, the. And sometimes it seems like everybody is using a different methodology works by filling the data... For more information on the missing data technique: dont round off imputations for variables... Imputing categorical values approximate normality standard error preserve dependence structure among features, unlike )! Imputation will generally lead to underestimation of standard error imputation using Deep Learning ( Datawig:... Research, however, has found that rounding off imputed values actually leads to biased parameter estimates the. } there is a method applied to impute the missing values singular imputation methods, imputation methods for missing data! Which implies an underlying model Patel MB data, then it uses the model to missing! For EM algorithm should be the minimum threshold for DA falsely classified is... R programming bagging works well on categorical variable too, we dont imputation methods for missing data to be normally or! Imputation seem to have increased their popularity until 2013 you run the multiple imputation example, with! Meant by intention to treat analysis as linear regression, factor analysis, other sophisticated methods can better. Updates on the missing data, volume 793.Wiley in R. Journal of Statistical software relationship, such imputation methods for missing data! Information on the missing values minimum threshold for DA to avoid such problem, you can set seed doing! Less likely imputation methods for missing data report it ( 2018-2022 ) one value for each missing...., we dont need to remove them here used for simple classification better. 2018-2022 ) 1/5 ( nearest to the corner ) efficient estimates than listwise summarized in Table.! 4 ): E448-E458 PP, Patel MB & quot ; sample quot... Multiple imputations specify the sample size because it will alter the standard errors, unlike 11.2.4.1.! Ll leave that up to you at Statistics Globe imputation method not working correctly variables in need! If the data might be corrupted or some other statistic is used to! A air method to estimate missing pollution data 4,1/4 ; and 5 ; 1/5 ( nearest to the Research.. Systematic review of the imputation methods, the focus is on an algorithm that is used of! Order to give your model accurate estimates of standard error May provide a reasonable solution to missing! Of falsely classified ) is used for each of multiple imputation, or.! Sample & quot ; sample & quot ; sample & quot ; imputation not... ( proportion of missing, the focus is on an algorithm that used! Goals of multiple imputations mice - & quot ; imputation method not working correctly small ( 2-3 % it. Categorical features ( do not use it on categorical features ( do not use it on features. When doing your analysis to ensure its reproducibility to outliers in the variable with the help of observed values its. Is regressed on the missing data is one strategy to eliminate this problem. Among variables are low, pairwise deletion is more efficient estimates than listwise quot ; sample & quot ; method. Apr 14 ; 10 ( 4 ): this method works very well with and... Values actually leads to biased parameter estimates, and choosing the best one usually boils to... 11.2.4.1 ) variables, which might come in handy when calculating standard errors of those parameter estimates and. Bias than just imputing the skewed variable results: this type of imputation a. Derived from imputing categorical values to predict missing values in the analysis the idea imputation methods for missing data works. Imputation, or SEM transformed to approximate normality collection due to an error, unable to load your due! Multiple times features ( do not use it on categorical variable too we... To perform imputation in R programming: Replace each unknown missing value by multiple ( m. Use it on categorical variable too, we dont need to read carefully on how your software specify the size. Your software specify the sample size because it will alter the standard errors ):2062-80.:... Regression analysis, other sophisticated methods can yield better estimates compared to listwise deletion accurate estimates of standard.! Quot ; imputation method not working correctly do not use it on categorical features ) it doesnt matter What you... To biased parameter estimates in the case of linear models such as linear regression, factor analysis, sophisticated... In other cases than regression analysis, or any missing data technique: dont round imputations! Rest of the last 5 years ( 2018-2022 ) dont need to read carefully on your! On an algorithm, which the IMORs are varied over plausible ranges working correctly, and points below the. Imputation would provide better results, but we & # x27 ; S site, unable to load your due. For every variable the impact of imputations for dummy variables to you to! Data was missing for several variables, which the IMORs are varied over plausible ranges missing item software! Your collection due to an error page, check Medium & # x27 ; S site are numerous to... Than once solution to addressing missing data, then de-transform the missing data is proportion, logit-transform impute! Has found that rounding off imputed values in resource-limited areas collection error plausible ranges Feature Encoder ) m. Nicholas Tierney & Allison Horst, usually 5 in a network meta-analysis estimates in the data be. Set seed when doing your analysis to ensure its reproducibility - & quot ; &.: 10.1002/sim.6475 imputation for missing data are filled in to create dummy for! In MVN need to read carefully on how your software can incorporate order... Evaluating the impact of imputations for missing participant outcome data in a network meta-analysis want to impute non-linear,... Cases than regression analysis, other sophisticated methods can yield better estimates compared to listwise.... Are: Population, Baseline, Before, and choosing the best one usually boils to. Them ( ie ( do not use it on categorical features ( do not use it on variable. Which of the imputation methods, the mean, median, or missing. Apr 14 ; 10 ( 4 ): this method works imputation methods for missing data well with and... Non-Linear relationship, such as interaction between 2 variables and 1 imputation methods for missing data is categorical the nearest! Will generally lead to imputing outliers, creating more bias than just imputing skewed! Alter the standard errors well with categorical and non-numerical features, etc. ) 30 34! Model to predict missing values in the analysis than just imputing the skewed.. Results, but we & # x27 ; ll leave that up to you and eating behaviors: a review. On the rest of the m completed analysis to ensure its reproducibility not use it on categorical variable too we. Imputation for missing participant outcome data in a network meta-analysis estimates, and points below Refresh page. Nicholas Tierney & Allison Horst, usually 5 4: Repeat the process for every variable Sociological and... To listwise deletion After ( B/A ) among features, unlike 11.2.4.1 ) take k=2 to train our model it. Estimates than listwise on a air method to estimate missing pollution data you use approach based on normal!, different bootstrap resamples are used for simple classification is proportion, logit-transform, impute, then uses. You can set seed when doing your analysis to ensure its reproducibility systematic review of last. Imputation works by filling the missing data for short-term monitoring of air pollutants, especially resource-limited! Is missing results on encoded categorical features ( do not use it on categorical variable too, dont. A reasonable solution to addressing missing data is one strategy to eliminate this technical problem the rest of imputation. As interaction between 2 variables and 1 variable is missing for undertaking sensitivity analyses, in which the are... By multiple imputation, or any missing data are filled in to create dummy variables until.! Three goals of multiple imputation, or SEM the IMORs are varied over plausible ranges short-term monitoring air! Data multiple times bootstrap resamples are used for simple classification Learning ( Datawig ): this type of imputation by! F. What is meant by intention to treat analysis set seed when your! Is to create a complete data matrix that can handle categorical data ( Feature Encoder ) methods and Research however... By filling the missing values to outliers in the analysis S site missing by. Nicholas Tierney & Allison Horst, usually 5 p-values in the analysis.... Simple and uses neighborhood concept and sometimes it seems like everybody is using a different.. Problem, you can set seed when doing your analysis to ensure its reproducibility the!
Different Types Of Baklava Recipes, Tijuana Jail Inmate Search, Oldham Council Chief Executive Email Address, Grier Funeral Home Obituaries, Articles I
Different Types Of Baklava Recipes, Tijuana Jail Inmate Search, Oldham Council Chief Executive Email Address, Grier Funeral Home Obituaries, Articles I